""We were the first religion to give power to women." REALLY???

Community outraged over book that tells Muslim men how to beat their wives

Community outraged over book that tells Muslim men how to beat their wives

6:15 pm, March 24th, 2012

ISLAMIC BOOKS AND SOUVENIRS, LOCATED GERRARD ST. E. WEST OF COXWELL AVE., IS WHERE TORONTONIAN ERIC BRAZAU BOUGHT A GIFT FOR MUSLIM COUPLE, A MARRIAGE GUIDE THAT INCLUDES ADVICE ON HOW TO CONTROL AND ‘PROPERLY’ BEAT A WIFE.

Credits: Terry Davidson/Toronto Sun

KEVIN CONNOR | QMI AGENCY

TORONTO — Farzana Baig says she is angry a book has surfaced in Toronto that advises Muslim men how to make their wives submissive through violence.The book called A Gift for Muslim Couple — which was being sold at Islamic Books and Souvenirs on Gerrard St. E. — advises men on “punishing women and the manner to discipline them” by restraints, scoldings and beatings.

“It is not like that in our community. This is upsetting. A wrong thing against our community. My husband doesn’t beat me. I haven’t heard of this. If it happens it is rare,” Baig said.

Her husband, a vice-president with Sunni mosque Jame Masjid Mississauga, had not heard of the book but plans to investigate on Monday.

“This is totally wrong. It should not be and I don’t know what to say. This doesn’t represent our community and I will look into it. This isn’t proper reading and it shouldn’t be out there. It makes the whole community look wrong,” he said.

Wasim Vania, president of the Islamic Society of Toronto, also condemns the book.

“We were the first religion to give power to women. It is sad that someone would write this. We don’t have hatred in our hearts and we don’t teach this. That book should have never entered Canada,” Vania said.

“It is a sad day to find such a book in Canada. As humans we can’t control everything but we should be able to control what goes on a book shelf. We as Canadian Muslims have respect for women. No gender is higher than the other. It is sad to find material like this and it should be pulled.”

The book is an insult to the Muslim community said Mohammed with the Muslim Welfare Centre, who asked his last name not be used.

“I have never heard of something like this. I’m surprised it was published and I am angry to be portrayed in this light,” he said.

What Would Niemöller Say?

I once heard Martin D. Niemöller tell of his incarceration at Dachau. His cell was in plain view of the gallows. Day after day he watched men and women go to their deaths. He could hear their cries, curses, and prayers. He declared that the gallows became his best teacher. Through that horrible experience he was haunted by two questions: “What will happen on the day they lead you there and put you to the test? When they put that rope around your neck, what will be your last words? Will they be, ‘Father, forgive them’ or will they be ‘Criminals! Scum?’ ”

Niemöller said that if Jesus had cried out in vengeance, there would have been no New Testament, no church, and no Christian history.
G. Curtis Jones, 1000 Illustrations for Preaching and Teaching (Nashville, TN: Broadman Press, 1986), 95-96.

Juxtaposition: What would one conclude as to the relative value of life vs book in conservative Islam?

Consider these two now old news events from Afghanistan:

First, this. American soldiers burn copies of the Koran that had been used for illegal prison communication.

Response: “If you burn the Koran, we will burn you.” Dozens killed in rioting.

Next, this. A mentally ill US soldier goes on a killing spree against innocent civilians.

Response: “The Afghan Taliban said it would take revenge for the deaths, in an emailed statement to media.” A press release.

So, what would one conclude as to the relative value of life vs book in conservative Islam?